How to achieve the right industrial floor?
by Dipl.-Chem. Dr. Peter Seidler
Industrial Floors 1991, International Colloquium Jan 15-17, 1991
2. The composition of concrete
Variability of binder and aggregates
The construction of an industrial floor using concrete (in contrast to, for example, asphaltic concrete with bitumen as binder or polymer concrete with reaction polymers as binder) really ought to be quite straight-forward, just as the principle already mentioned for the basic demands made on a floor appear very simple. One can sum it up in terms of a six-step method:
- Take any sort of sand (aggregate).
- Portland cement as a low-priced binder.
- Add enough water for easy working.
- Smooth the surface (by machine or by hand).
- Cut the necessary joints.
- Wait until the slab has set.
|
Then the factory can begin production and the fork-lift trucks can drive around.
In reality, however, the construction of an industrial floor poses many difficulties owing to the variety of service conditions and the variability of the materials used. This is demonstrated by the high incidence of damage. In the case of floors made of concrete with added reaction polymer at least 10 variabilities can be listed:
- Type of cement
- Type of aggregate
- Granulometry of aggregates
- Type and quantity of reinforcing materials (e.g. fibres)
- Application (e.g. compacting, time, water)
- Ambient conditions (e.g. temperature, air humidity, wind)
- Post-treatment (e.g. plastic sheet, curing agents)
- Type of surface preparation
- Strengthening by impregnation
- Reaction polymer composition
|
This list does not include the type of moisture barrier under the concrete slab. Practical experience shows that failure to with polythene sheeting, as the minimum measure, can be detrimental to the quality of the concrete slab in many respects seal.
Why does concrete not always succeed?
There are many possible errors which can occur when placing concrete. I have summarized the most frequently occurring causes of defects and damages in the following list:
|
Types of damages
- insufficiently hardened
- is powdering, porous
- shows cracks and breaks
- is rough
- is contaminated with oil or chemicals
- is worn, has grooves, shows ruts
|
|
Causes and responsibility of damages
Responsibility of the construction management
- premature stress
- heating, radiant heat
- draught
Responsibility of the manufacturer
- bad grain-size distribution
- too many fines
- insufficient grain strength
- too many filterable constituents
- contamination
- humus acids
- swelling grains (such as marl or brown coal)
- frozen sand
- the use of contaminated water
- too small or too large proportion of binder
- wrong proportion of additive
- too much water
- insufficient mixing
Responsibility of the contractor
- too long storage before placement
- insufficient compaction
- too early or too much smoothing
- too little thickness
- drying out not uniform
- due to strong sun radiation
- due to draught
- too large distances between joints
External influences
- effect of frost during solidification and hardening
- improper maintenance
- improper use
|
The simple 6-step method described above is not enough by itself if one wishes to avoid all the causes of errors and defects. That is undoubtedly one of the reasons why this colloquium is again being attended by more than 100 participants who have come to find out which methods produce the right industrial floor and/or how existing methods can be improved.
What do cement and concrete cost?
Let us take a look at the cost side of concrete and reaction polymers. Costs rise by approximately a factor of 10 in each case from aggregate through to cement and polymer dispersions for modification purposes and on to reaction polymers.
If one assumes the following prices (in Germany) ex works:
| |
Aggregates (silo) |
EUR per ton 8 |
| |
Portland cement (silo) |
EUR per ton 90 |
| |
Steel mats |
EUR per ton 900 |
| |
Polymer dispersion |
EUR per ton 2.500 |
| |
Reaction polymer |
EUR per ton 210.000 |
and if one assumes the following concrete mix proportions (e.g. for vacuum concrete):
| |
Portland cement |
|
310 kg |
EUR 28 |
| |
Water |
|
170 kg |
|
| |
Sand |
0/2 mm |
485 kg 26% |
|
| |
Gravelly sand |
2/8 mm |
225 kg 12% |
|
| |
Gravel |
8/16 mm |
725 kg 39% |
|
| |
Crushed gravel |
16/22 mm |
435 kg 23% 100% |
EUR 14 |
| |
B 25 concrete |
|
2350 kg/cu.m |
EUR 42 |
or if the above is abbreviated to the following % by weight composition per 1 cu.m. ready-mix concrete:
| |
Z 35 F cement |
310 kg |
13,2% |
EUR 28 |
| |
Water |
170 kg |
7,2% |
|
| |
Aggregate 0/22 mm |
1870 kg |
79,6% |
EUR 14 |
| |
B 25 concrete |
2350 kg/cu.m |
EUR 42 |
One obtains the following characteristics:
| |
Water/cement ratio |
0.55/0.46 |
| |
Grain content |
390 kg |
| |
Consistency |
K 2 |
| |
Slump |
38 cm |
My aim in quoting these figures is to encourage you to apply the method of constructional value analysis to concrete slabs. No doubt various savings can be made here.
|